Clynelish vs Johnnie Walker Gold Label

The Striding Cat

Clynelish, a Highland distillery I've heard a lot of good things about, and I've read a lot of good reviews for - both for their own bottlings, as well as independent bottlings. It's also often mentioned as well-regarded among blenders as well, e.g. Compass Box bases several of their blended malts around Clynelish. My own experience with the distillery has unfortunately been limited, so it's finally time to educate myself.

I decided to start with the official 14-year-old release (46% abv) and I will compare it to Johnnie Walker Gold Label Reserve (40% abv), the Johnnie Walker known to be built around a core of Clynelish.

First up, the single malt. I find the nose a nice balancing act between a potpourri of fruits (black currants, oranges and green apples) and right amount of wood (oak and sawdust). There is a very pleasant trail of peat smoke in the background and it's slightly spirituous. Some of the sweetness reminds me of honey, like honey soap or honey candles. With water, the nose mellows a bit. The spirituous part becomes more briny and maritime. To the taste it's more woody than fruity. The black currants have taken a back seat. Other berries have been baked into a pie. With water it becomes too easy to drink. The finish is dry and medium-long.

Compared to the single malt, the Johnnie Walker is more spirituous and medicinal on the nose, almost phenolic, albeit still very light smokiness. Hint of glue stick, but also some berries. A mix of tart lingonberries and ripe bananas. With water the smoke takes you to an outdoor clam bake. To be honest, I would have a hard time picking this out as a blend among single malts. It has a slightly more spirituous, solvent, glue-type character that I find in other blends, but it is very well-balanced here. On the tongue it is very smooth and the wood character comes out more. Maybe some of that famous Clynelish waxiness is also present. Water helps malt and cereal notes come forward but does not necessarily improve it.

You can definitely tell that Johnnie Walker Gold is in the same family and a good guess is that it’s been derived from a fair amount of Clynelish. I like both a lot and Gold might almost bump Green from the top spot of my favorite Johnnie Walker. I would venture to say I prefer the Gold over the official Clynelish, at least as a every(other)day sipping dram.

Sssh, don't let the cat out of the bag!

As a bonus, I decided to throw in another Clynelish in the mix. A single cask bottling from the nice folks at Scotch Malt Whisky Society: No. 26.89 'An exotic tearoom experience' (27 years old, ex-sherry refill butt, 56.6% abv). For you that don’t know, Scotch Malt Whisky Society (SMWS) is an independent bottler and membership club that bottles a wide range of single casks for its members. They for some reason or another deliberately don't reveal the distillery on the label but give it a unique number instead. They also give their bottles quirky names with sometimes even quirkier tasting notes. With the power of Google, we can figure out that No.26.89 was actually distilled at Clynelish.

First impression of the nose is "Wow!", this is why I love whisky. Fine sherry, berry compote with peaches, light peatiness, honey and a sweetness that reminds me of blueberry pie served with Sauce Marsán (Instant Vanilla Cream). Followed by strawberry shortcake ice cream, but also Crayola crayons (Is this the Clynelish waxiness everyone refers to?). It is prickly on the tongue, light with a nice mouthfeel. A light pleasant smokiness and you can taste spices in the back. With water, the vanilla becomes stronger on the nose. It also tames the palette and makes it easier to drink. The finish is long and lingering with spices reminiscent of Swedish ginger snaps.

An excellent foray into the world of Clynelish. I've already ordered more samples of this fine distillery.

Clynelish 14 year old: 7±.5, Johnnie Walker Gold Label Reserve: 7±.5 and SMWS 26.89: 8.5±.5.